News

Alliance for the Wild Rockies Persists in Fight to Protect Grizzly Bears in Idaho

Alliance for the Wild Rockies Persists in Fight to Protect Grizzly Bears in Idaho
Grizzly sow and cubs near Fishing Bridge, Yellowstone National Park by Jim Peaco; May 2015 NPS

Selkirk Grizzly Bears

The Selkirk grizzly bear population is in dire straits. There are only about 50 bears in the population, and the minimum needed for recovery is 100 bears. The bears suffer from human-caused mortality at a rate of about 2.7 bears killed by humans per year, and those rates violate the limits set by the government for recovery. This mortality rate is so high for this tiny population that there are only three years on record with higher mortality since record keeping began over 30 years ago. There is really no hope of recovery for this imperiled population unless the government starts complying with the law.

Grizzly photo by Glenn Phillips
Grizzly photo by Glenn Phillips

The Lawsuit -- 8 Years & Still Going Strong

The legal issue in this case comes from the 2003 Healthy Forest Restoration Act. In part, the Healthy Forests Restoration Act allows the Forest Service to exempt logging projects in the “Wildland Urban Interface” from environmental analysis and protection measures normally required under the National Environmental Policy Act. This weakens protections for fish and wildlife habitat under the National Forest Management Act and Endangered Species Act.

Importantly, the “wildland-urban interface” is defined by the law as a very specific location. Yet, the Forest Service routinely ignores the legal definition and attempts to misuse the exemption to log miles away from communities to benefit the private profit margins of the timber industry.

Grizzly sow with cubs by Glenn Phillips
Grizzly sow with cubs by Glenn Phillips

In this case, the federal court in Idaho and the federal appellate court have both found that the Forest Service violated the law by ignoring the definition of wildland urban interface. The government’s weak argument in response was that public comments on the Hanna Flats project had not been specific enough to notify the Forest Service that it was breaking the law. In other words, the government claimed ignorance of its own laws. In June, the federal appellate court rejected that weak defense, holding that the public does not need to submit public comments when the Forest Service refuses to conduct an environmental review.

The government is not happy that it continues to lose this case. It does not want to follow the law. And so, this month, the Trump Administration filed a request for rehearing “en banc” of this case. This means that the government wants to reargue this case in front of a panel of 11 federal judges. The outcome will be legally-binding precedent for all future cases in all federal courts within the Ninth Circuit: California, Arizona, Nevada, Idaho, Montana, Oregon, Washington, Alaska, and Hawaii.

We Need Your Help

We will not give up the fight for the imperiled Selkirk grizzly bear in Idaho. We will hold the government accountable when it breaks its own laws.

Grizzly with cub by Glenn Phillips
Grizzly with cub by Glenn Phillips

Join Us.

Please make a donation to the Alliance for the Wild Rockies so that we can hire the best lawyers in the country to protect the important legal precedent set in this case.

Mike Garrity is the Executive Director of the Alliance for the Wild Rockies.

Help us protect the Northern Rockies

Your donation to our litigation war chest ensures there is something left to protect when NREPA finally becomes law.